Skip to Content

Best Crib Mattress Reviews 2022 – Top 5 Picks

They grow so fast!

Isn’t it amazing how, within a few months, or even weeks, a baby stops looking fragile and week?

Suddenly, their eyes dart around, and you cannot have their attention for more than a few minutes.

At that time, they outgrow their clothes, and you wonder, what am I feeding this little angel?

As it turns out, it’s not all in what they eat; babies grow faster because they sleep a lot.

The human growth hormone is at a high concentration when sleeping.

So, even though suckling facilitates growth, sleeping on the best crib mattress plays a bigger role.

However, you have to make sure that the crib mattress is safe and won’t cause suffocation or allergies.

5 Best Crib Mattress Reviews 2022

Kids are as adorable as they are fragile.

A sneeze, though normal, needs monitoring and sleeping in the wrong position could harm the child’s body.

This means that you must have a safe high- crib mattress.

Searching for one is challenging but, not when you have a trusted provider such as Safety 1st.

Safety 1st stays true to their name by giving you the safest baby crib mattresses on the market.

The main safety features include the use of hypoallergenic materials which are free of phthalates and lead.

It also fits the standard toddler bed or crib so they won’t fall to the empty side.

Comfort – as mentioned above, a child’s body is fragile, and though your bed is comfortable, you may not sleep well (any new parent knows how bad it is caring for a child when sleep deprived).

Rather than competing for comfort on one bed, why not get everyone their spacious and comfortable bed?

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress is made with a high-density thermos-bonded fiber core which provides as firm but comfortable support.

It is also lightweight and durable meaning that your child will outgrow it.

Wondering if it is easy to clean? It is!

Thanks to the safe vinyl cover which is waterproof, you’ll only need to wipe it clean with a wet cloth.


  • Achieves GreenGuard Gold Certification.
  • The mattress is very lightweight yet durable long-lasting use.
  • Vinyl cover is waterproof and wipes clean easily.
  • Fits perfectly to standard cribs.


  • The mattress might to too firm and too hard for some babies.

Did you know that infants and children, in general, spend most of their early lives sleeping?

No wonder they are beautiful, rested, and chubby!

But, here is the kicker – they rely on comfort for them to sleep as well as they do.

While sleeping in the same bed is great for bonding, sleeping alone in their cribs makes them independent and also enhances the quality of their sleep.

For these benefits, you’ve got to get a heavenly light blue mattress from Safety 1st.

We may know of the wondrous dreams babies have but, this excellent light blue high-density crib mattress with a thermo-bonded core will make sure that he or she sleeps all too well.

For safety while babies sleep, Safety 1 st use phthalates and lead-free materials.

You won’t have to worry about exposing your child to toxic chemicals early on in life.

This mattress is durable (with a wear and tear resistant cover) but lightweight.

It is also easy to clean thanks to the waterproof vinyl cover.

In case you are looking for an attractive design for the new crib mattress, then you will like the intricate star pattern on this one.


  • Lead and phthalates free - Safe material for infants
  • The mattress is very lightweight and very comfortable.
  • Vinyl cover is waterproof and durable to resist wear and tear
  • Fits perfectly to standard crib size.


  • Not as firm as other mattresses.
  • The cover may tear off after some time.

Nothing is more satisfying to a parent than watching their child sleep peacefully.

Not having to think about the stiffness of the mattress and if your child’s spinal cord is well-aligned makes a happy parent.

For this peace of mind, you will have to get the Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress.

This excellent soy foam mattress is not only hypoallergenic but also firm and comfortable.

When you hear firm, you may think that it could harm your baby but it wouldn’t because this Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress has a high-density core and the added cotton cushioning creating a balanced sleeping environment.

The safety of this mattress got approved by the CertiPUR-US, and it got its certification making it a more trusted brand.

The mattress is free from phthalates, mercury, lead, formaldehyde, TCEP or TDCPP flame retardants and PBDES and it got a GreenGuard Gold certification.

This certification is for mattresses or baby products that pass the CPSIA tests and meet ASTM standards.

Thanks to the waterproof pearl-embossed cover, this crib mattress is very easy to clean and maintain.

The cover ensures that you live with the mattress for a long time.

Well, your first child will outgrow it, but you won’t have to buy another one for your second child.

Respiratory infections are parents’ worst fear in children, and though you cannot prevent all infections, you have control over an infection from allergens on the beddings.

This mattress is what you need for that extra level of protection.

The pearl-embossed cover also has a lock-stitched binding which prevents allergens from clinging on the mattress.

Because of these features, Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress got voted America’s Most Recommended baby mattress four years in a row.


  • Very firm and durable.
  • Very lightweight.
  • Pearl embossed waterproof and stain-resistant cover for an easy-clean.
  • Fits perfectly to standard crib size.


  • Expensive price.
  • The mattress might be to too firm for some babies.

The secret to a happy baby is enough food and more sleep.

For the latter, you’ll have to get the most comfortable mattress for your child’s crib.

One of the most important feature to look for when shopping for the mattress is the hypoallergenic factor, and that is what you get from the Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress or Toddler Bed Mattress.

The materials used in the design are allergen-free.

The mattress is a unique blend of foam, and this creates a perfect blend of safety and comfort.

The encasement is made using anti-flame materials, and it is waterproof.

To meet all fire safety regulations; the mattress comes with an inner fiberglass lining free from toxins and chemicals.

The aesthetic appearance of a crib or the nursery helps in putting you, and your child at ease and this mattress enhance the aesthetics with its polka dot design.

The other excellent feature of this mattress is its antimicrobial resistance.

It is resistant to mold, dust mites, and bacteria making it ideal for allergic children especially if suffering from asthma.

To make your child more comfortable, Milliard went a step further and used their unique technology to design mattresses which allow for maximum air flow and temperature regulation.

This technology also facilitates weight distribution by contouring gently to the curves of your baby’s body relieving muscle pain, stress and aches.


  • Very comfortable.
  • Durable thanks to the high-quality materials.
  • Antiallergenic and antimicrobial making it ideal for asthmatic kids.
  • It has temperature regulation capabilities.
  • Provides excellent support to your babies.


  • The mattress might be too hard and too noisy for some.

If you are looking for a star-studded light pink crib mattress for your little girl, get the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Stars a Plenty Baby Mattress.

As the name suggests, it is heavenly, and your child will have the most peaceful dreams.

This experience results from the mattress’ design which incorporates a high-density thermo-bonded core which offers a high and a comfortable level of support.

You also have the lightweight design which doesn’t affect the durability of the crib mattress.

The cover has a beautiful intricate star pattern and made from vinyl; it is waterproof.

This cover also resists wear and tear, and it is easy to clean.

We all worry about the chemicals in baby products and wonder if the materials used in the design of the crib mattresses are safe.

Well, you should know that this mattress is free of lead and phthalates and it meets the federal flammability standard 16 CFR 1633.

It also has low chemical emissions, and this is why this Safety 1 st mattress meets the GreenGuard Gold standards.


  • It is lightweight design.
  • Vinyl cover is waterproof and durable to resist wear and tear.
  • Lead and phthalates free making it safe.


  • Not as firm as other mattresses.
  • The cover may tear off after some time.

How to Buy the Safest Crib Mattress for Your Baby

  • Age
    You just have to get a new mattress. Make sure it hasn’t been in the store for far too long because hygiene is critical.

    Mold grows in old and improperly stored mattresses, and that increases the risk of disease. You really don’t wish to deal with spit outs and diaper leaks from a stranger, do you?

  • Type of Mattress
    There are two main types of crib mattresses: foam and innerspring. They are equally good but, you have to get a high-quality mattress regardless of the type.

    In case you need to choose one over the other – for a foam mattress, the denser and heavier, the better. For an inner-spring mattress, look out for border rods and the number of coils (between 135 and 150 coils).

    Note that an expensive innerspring mattress isn’t necessarily the best. There is a third type of crib mattress, a more expensive option but the best – an organic mattress.

  • Quality
    A high-quality mattress isn’t just costly, it comes with a thick puncture resistant cover, it has triple or double laminates, and it won’t dry out fast.

    When considering the quality, you need to have resilience in mind. A resilient mattress regains it shape faster if you press and release the middle.

  • Firmness
    A good mattress is firm, and though it looks stiff to you, it will work well for your baby. You can know this if it snaps back readily without conforming to the shape of your hand.

    As you think of firmness, you may also want to consider the mattress’ density. A high-density mattress is always preferable to a low density one.

  • Weight
    Most conventional foam mattresses weigh almost 8 pounds, memory foams about 20 pounds and innerspring mattresses weigh up to 25 pounds.

  • Cover and Venting
    The cover, also called ticking, should be water resistant with triple or double reinforcement of the laminate. It should be wear resistant too.

    For venting, ensure that the mattress has small holes on the sides to let air and odors out.

  • Cleaning
    Two things; it should be waterproof and machine washable. Your baby will pee and poop on the mattress, don’t get one that will make it hard to clean well resulting in unwanted smells in the house.

  • Safety
    A safe crib mattress for your child is free of chemicals like lead and phthalates. At the same time, it shouldn’t pose any risk of suffocation.

    Please note that air mattresses aren't safe for use by babies.

  • Price
    The prices of crib mattresses vary, and the most expensive or the cheapest crib mattress isn’t necessarily the best.

    Look through the features above and ensure that it is durable, safe, comfortable, firm, and worth the price.


Whether you are a first-time parent or not, getting a high-quality crib mattress comes highly recommended because though bonding is important, a crib next to your bed or in the nursery makes it possible for you to get some hours of good rest.

It also builds independence. The only way for your child to experience these is if they sleep on a comfortable, safe, and warm crib mattress.

This brings us to the question, among these five crib mattresses, which is our best choice?

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress - Editor's Choice

These are all great mattresses, but we recommend Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress as our pick for crib mattress. It has a waterproof vinyl cover and free of lead and phthalates. It’s safe and received a GREENGUARD Gold certification. It is also lightweight and fairly easy to clean or flip. Your child will love the comfort of this mattress in their crib.

Product Brand: Safety 1st

Product Currency: USD

Product In-Stock: InStock

Editor's Rating: