Skip to Content

Best Pacifier for Breastfed Baby Reviews 2022 – Top 5 Picks

It is not unusual that we see babies using pacifiers. But why do they need these products anyway?

Experts say that pacifiers can soothe a baby and satisfy its sucking reflex.

There are many types of pacifiers in the market, and we are sure that you would want the best pacifier for breastfed baby.

In this article, we will review and discuss the five best pacifiers available in the market right now.

But before we get into that, babies need a lot of products during their early years that we need to know of.

One of the most important things about looking after a newborn is a formula for breastfed baby.

Make sure you get the right brand, right nutrients, and vitamins to keep that baby healthy.

Another important product that many parents search for are bottles for breastfed babies. You will need to buy one made of non-toxic plastic materials.

After all, your baby will be putting this bottle into their mouths. It is the same case with pacifiers.

Always look for safe products, especially when it comes to those which a baby will suck or bite on.

Now let us get into the reviews of what we think is the best pacifier for breastfed baby and some other options:

5 Best Pacifier for Breastfed Baby Reviews 2022

In our opinion, the MAM Start Newborn Pacifier is the best pacifier for breastfed baby available in the market right now.

We chose this product as the number one because it has a symmetrical design so that there is no right side up.

The benefit this feature provides is that you will not have to worry about putting in the pacifier the wrong way.

Your baby will self adjust the binky.

The product contains only safe and soft materials and comes complete with a self-sterilizing case.

All you have to do is add some water, and it will clean itself in three minutes.

Sometimes the shield of the pacifier can be suffocating. 

Still, with this one, it has openings that will allow your baby’s skin to breathe without any problem.


  • Easy to grip and suck the nipple
  • Free from BPA, silicone material
  • Smooth and effective design
  • Easy to clean and easy to dry


  • The size of the nipple may be a little big for some babies
  • Water may get stuck inside sometimes

Pacifiers need to be soft so that it does not hurt the baby’s gums or any part of its mouth.

TommeeTippee Closer To Nature Soother Pacifier is a very spongy and comfortable product made of super-soft silicone.

You can easily introduce this to your baby in between feeds to keep him or her calm.

It makes sure that the child will not reject the nipple by having a skin-like surface.

It has an orthodontic design and slightly curves away from the baby’s face to ensure better airflow.

The design prevents rashes and allergies.


  • Easy to clean
  • Free from harmful materials
  • The skin-like surface enables a smooth transition for babies
  • The baby can hold on to the pacifier and not drop it


  • Little fingers can get stuck in the hole for the clip
  • If water gets into the rim, it will start to grow mold after some time

One reason why babies reject certain pacifiers during the introduction stage is that the shape of the nipple feels foreign inside their mouths.

The Evenflo Feeding Balance Plus Pacifier has a cylindrical design that fits right into the natural curves of the baby’s tongue.

It has an easy-grip design to make sure that the baby can hold on to it.

You will not have trouble grabbing it either, thanks to this design. It is free of all toxic materials.


  • It will not cause mouth fatigue
  • Your baby can grab the pacifier effortlessly
  • It is lightweight
  • Easy to clean


  • Some babies may find it slightly long
  • Difficult to spot it at night because of its translucent nature

As mentioned earlier, all parents try to find the safest products for their babies.

It is unacceptable to give children anything even slightly toxic.

BIBS has made a Natural Rubber Baby Pacifier that is 100% natural, as the name suggests.

The rubber material which makes up the nipple is fully natural and resembles the feel and touch of a real nipple.

Your baby will not feel like it is putting a pacifier inside its mouth, rather, a mother’s breast.


  • Very easy to clean
  • Classic and effective design
  • Chewable nipple ideal for teething babies
  • Easy to hold


  • The nipple sizes may differ
  • It is small and bigger babies may put the entire thing into their mouths

The Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother Pacifier comes in a pack of two.

The manufactures have made the whole body from food-grade silicone.

There are two large holes on both sides of the pacifier to ensure that there is breathability.

You can pop them into the top rack of the dishwasher or steam them in a sanitizing bag to clean them.

This product meets ASTM safety standards.


  • Ideal size for teething babies
  • Easy to clean
  • Collapsible handle


  • Not small enough for newborns
  • It collects dust very easily


Now that you know some of the best pacifiers available in the market right now, you can make an informed decision.

There are a few pointers that you need to keep in mind while selecting a binky for your baby.

Try to get one that feels like a real nipple. Babies will outright spit it out if it feels like plastic or any other foreign object.

Also, make sure that there are not toxic or harmful materials. It should always be BPA free.

MAM Start Newborn Pacifiers - Editor's Choice

Amongst all the pacifiers mentioned above, we think MAM Start Newborn Pacifier will be the best choice. This pick is because it’s easy to clean, easy to dry, has a smooth and natural design, and is free from BPA.

Product Brand: MAM

Product Currency: USD

Product In-Stock: InStock

Editor's Rating: